By John P. Mello Jr.
Apr 20, 2015 3:32 PM PT
Google on Monday released an update to Android Wear — the first significant feature refresh for its wearable device software since its introduction more than a year ago.
“This update is overdue,” said Ian Fogg, senior director and head of the mobile and telecoms team at IHS Technology.
“With other products, Google adds features fairly continuously,” he told TechNewsWorld. “Android Wear hasn’t had as much focus from Google over the last year as some of its other products.”
The new features of Android Wear, announced just days before the scheduled delivery of the first Apple Watches, include the following:
- Hands-free operation — with a wrist flick, you can shuffle between virtual cards of information.
- Watch-to-phone connection over WiFi — as long as your phone is online and your watch is connected to a WiFi network, they’ll be able to talk to each other.
- Always-on extended to apps — apps can remain visible on the watch face without the device dozing off.
- Fancy Emoji search — you can draw an emoji on the watch face and Android Wear will display the closest match to what you’ve drawn.
The new features initially will be rolled out on the LG Watch Urbane.
LG Watch Urbane
They will become available for the other six Android watches — Moto 360, LG G Watch, Asus Zenwatch, Samsung Gear Live, SmartWatch 3 and LG G Watch R — in the coming weeks.
Row, Row, Row Your Cards
Even with its new wrist-flick navigation features, it will still be difficult to navigate on Android watches, maintained John Feland, CEO of
Argus Insights. That’s because Android Wear is built on cards containing information, unlike the application-centered interface used by Apple Watch.
“Rather than navigating in two-dimensional space, as you do with the Apple Watch, with Android you move linearly — so you have to swipe and swipe and swipe,” Felund told TechNewsWorld. “It’s a row, row, row your boat problem, because you’re constantly rowing through options on the device.”
Hands-free operation of smartwatches is a challenge facing their designers, and the Android wrist flick is unlikely to solve that problem, said Canalys analyst Daniel Matte.
“I doubt that it will be useful,” he told TechNewsWorld. “I think there’ll be too many false positives to make it work well for consumers.”
Always-on apps is another feature that can deliver both benefits and bumps.
“The always-on thing can be very useful because one complaint about the Apple Watch by reviewers is that there’s a pause before the screen comes on,” said Bob O’Donnell, founder and chief analyst with Technalysis Research.
“No one wants a pause when you glance at your watch,” he told TechNewsWorld. “When you glance at your watch, it’s got be there.”
Always-on has its drawbacks, though, argued Canalys’ Matte. “Anything that’s always-on is a waste of battery life. When you’re not looking at the watch, it should be off.”
With the addition of hand-drawn emojis, Android is keeping pace with Apple in the fun department.
“It’s a nice novel thing, but that novelty won’t drive the utility you need for long-term consumer adoption. There’s only so many custom emojis you can do before you’re bored,” said Argus’ Feland.
“It’s like putting a Union Jack on the top of your Mini Cooper,” he continued. “It’s fun, but it won’t increase your gas mileage. Fun drives those first few sales, but utility drives long-term adoption.”
However, when it comes to the long term, Android Wear may be in a better position to respond to market change than Apple Watch, suggested James Moar, a research analyst with
“Android Wear has a much more flexible platform than Apple, both in terms of software and hardware,” he told TechNewsWorld.
“While this means that at present quality control will be an issue for Android Wear, it will allow successful apps to show and lead much more easily than Apple’s tightly regulated system,” Moar pointed out.
“This adaptability is key to Android Wear and is a core advantage for Google,” he added.
In addition, it allows Google to produce more varied form factors than the Apple Watch.
“Fashion elements are easier to emphasize with more possible varieties,” Moar said.”It also makes it more amenable to branded partnerships which can drive fashion-based interest.”