But the ongoing battle for internet freedom has proved that clicktivism isn’t just about passive engagement with a cause. While it’s all too easy to ‘like’ a cause, leading to what David Carr describes as “favoriting fatigue” in an article in the New York Times, some clicks can count in the real world.
Join The Times of India campaign for neutral internet
It all started when the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (Trai) posted a vaguely worded and complicated discussion paper on net neutrality and called for public responses to it. “Clearly, many people understood that some of the proposals put forward by Trai in its paper threatened the internet as they knew it,” says Anja Kovacs, who directs the Internet Democracy Project and has closely followed online activism in India.
READ ALSO: People have taken ownership of the net, Nikhil Pahwa says
Soon, an unlikely collective of techies, lawyers, journalists and even stand-up comics had banded together. Some of them — such as tech entrepreneur Kiran Jonnalagadda and journalist Nikhil Pahwa — had been writing and tweeting about the issue for a while but the Trai paper galvanized them. “I dropped everything and asked for help. Kiran, (lawyers) Apar Gupta amd Raman Chima, Sandeep Pillai, standup group All India Bakchod and several Reddit India users (some of whom remain anonymous), started getting involved,” says Pahwa, who is the founder of Medianama. The only common factor was their love for internet and an acute worry what this policy consultation might do to destroy its open and equal nature.
READ ALSO: What is net neutrality and why it is important?
Though scattered across India, once they came together online, this ‘apolitical collective’ was able to rope in engineers, developers, open source activists, entrepreneurs, policy experts, lawyers and journalists as volunteers.
The best way to counter propaganda and opposition was to get people involved. An abridged version of the voluminous Trai paper was posted online, and a FAQ section created on a public Google Doc. “Many came forward to answer the questions and that exercise helped create an understanding of the situation,” explains Pahwa. By the time, Jonnalagadda and a few other developers set up the savetheinternet.in website by April 1, there was enough information and data points. Lawyers Gupta and Chima had also decoded the legalese and prepared cogent answers to Trai’s 20 questions. This was turned into a ready-to-use email template for users to hit ‘send’.
And send they did. The flood of emails to the Trai inbox number is already 803,723 and counting. The results of the social media backlash are evident — with e-commerce retailer Flipkart pulling out of Airtel Zero and several websites backing out of Facebook and Reliance’s internet.org. “I was hoping to get around 15,000 responses to counter, say, 15 from the telecom lobby. Now, people make fun of me because I said that,” laughs Pahwa. In this case, what also struck a chord was the idea of a bunch of young guys using tech to take on mismanagement by the older generation and corporate greed, says entrepreneur Mahesh Murthy. “We were telling them we like things on the internet as they are now.”
But it is hard to sustain online outrage without an action plan, relentless groundwork and some comic warfare. So, when the contentious paper came out on March 27, the website was followed by AIB’s punchy video that decoded the concept and took irreverent potshots at those who wanted to limit access while urging people to write to Trai. A lot of the lessons for the campaign came from the US where a John Oliver video turned the tide in the net neutrality debate. “We had seen that several people don’t take internet petitions seriously. Also, we wanted to follow the proper legal course in this issue and not hold dharnas,” says Jonnalagadda.
It is also important for campaigns to result in doable action. As Kovacs points out, savetheinternet.in and netneutrality. in gave users practical tools to respond before the April 24 deadline. The team also kept clarifying doubts and complex concepts on social media and also had an AMA (ask me anything) chat on Scrollback on Saturday while the ‘other side’ stuck to big words and jargon.
Of course, like every movement, this one too has attracted criticism. The proneutrality band has been branded as socialist and utopian and there were intense arguments amongst supporters. “Disagreements and arguments are not unique to the activism online,” says Pranesh Prakash, policy director at Centre for Internet and Society.
Click here for complete coverage on net neutrality
Earlier in the debate, Prakash had said he’d received strong pushback from friends and allies when he spoke about the possible benefits of non-competitive zero rating, an example would be allowing companies to offer free access to their sites and apps via an arrangement with a telecom company — if effective competition exists. Airtel Zero and Reliance’s Internet.org claim to do the same though most supporters remain critical. Says Prakash: “There might’ve been differences. But the fact that a lot of people are thinking about effects of ‘free’, and comparing it to predatory pricing shows that #savetheinternet is one of the better examples of engaged activism.”
Online campaigns have previously also successfully mobilized people to get involved in issues they do not know much about, says author Nilanajana Roy, who is an influential voice on Twitter. The J&K flood relief efforts last year started on Twitter but got volunteers moving on the ground, she says. “People don’t always realize what they care strongly about so, despite the risk of compassion fatigue or armchair volunteerism, it’s worth having some online activism,” says Roy.
Meanwhile, those behind the savetheinternet campaign are struggling with their new-found identity as “activists”. “I think of myself as a venture capitalist and marketing consultant, not a khadi kurta-jholawala from JNU,” says Mahesh Murthy, among those who strongly support the movement.
And at the end of the day, most of these activists would like to go back to their cubicles, free to browse or start a business. But not before they’ve tried to keep the internet open.